The Institute for Work & Health has scanned the research and called on experts to get the latest word on what we know – and don’t know – about the effects of shift work on employee health. There are certainly areas for concern, so more research on ways to protect shift workers is the logical next step.
We live in a 24/7 world. From around-the-clock patient care in hospitals to overnight services in hotels and restaurants, there’s work to be done from sundown to sunrise. For more than a quarter of Canada’s employees, that means working shifts.
Shift work may be a social and economic necessity, but it is not necessarily a benign one.
Research on the effects of shift work on health goes back for decades, says Dr. Ron Saunders, a senior scientist at the Institute for Work & Health (IWH).
However, some research generated in the last few years – and the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) finding that long-term shift work probably increases the risk of cancer – is really getting people’s attention.
The experts weigh in
About 100 invited guests gathered together in Toronto in mid-April to hear leading experts discuss what we do and do not know about the effects of shift work on employee health. The symposium, co-hosted by the Institute for Work & Health (IWH) and the Occupational Cancer Research Centre (OCRC), was designed to “assess how strong the evidence is with respect to shift work as the causal factor for various disorders,” says IWH’s Dr. Ron Saunders.
In particular, the symposium addressed the strength of the research evidence with respect to the role of shift work in cancer, cardiovascular disease, sleep disturbances, work injuries and pregnancy outcomes. Saunders says another symposium focusing on policy implications and strategies to minimize the risks of shift work may follow.
“Shift work won’t go away. It’s part of our economy,” he says. “Therefore, the next step is to determine what we can do to lessen its potential health effects.”
The symposium was held just as this newsletter was going to press, so its key findings cannot be presented here. However, symposium proceedings are in the works. Watch for information about them at: www.iwh.on.ca.
This heightened attention spurred IWH and the Occupational Cancer Research Centre to co-host a symposium in mid-April on the possible health effects of shift work. The invitation-only event brought together experts from Canada, the United States and Europe to review the research evidence linking shift work to illness and injury (see box at right).
The symposium coincided with an upcoming Issue Briefing from IWH. Penned by Saunders, the briefing provides an overview of research findings on shift work as a cause of cancer, cardiovascular disease, gastrointestinal disorders, workplace injuries, sleep disorders and more.
Shift work tied to range of health effects
Shift work – essentially anything other than a regular daytime work schedule – is a reality for 26 per cent of full-time workers aged 19-64, according to Statistics Canada. About two-thirds of protective service workers (police officers, firefighters, security guards), 45 per cent of health workers, 40 per cent of sales and service workers, and 42 per cent of primary industry workers (farm workers, miners, forestry workers, etc.) are engaged in shift work.
As outlined in the Issue Briefing, the latest research points to the following about the health effects of shift work:
- Long-term night shift workers probably have an elevated risk of breast cancer, and a potentially elevated risk of colorectal cancer. The IARC expert working group concluded that “shift work that involves circadian disruption is probably carcinogenic to humans.”
- Elevated risks of gastrointestinal disorders, mental health problems (including depression) and preterm delivery during pregnancy are indicated among shift workers.
- Shift workers, particularly those working nights, face a higher risk of getting hurt on the job than regular day workers. The risk is particularly high in the second hour of a night shift.
- The association between shift work and heart disease is inconsistent. Although previous studies found a link between the two, a more recent systematic review found only limited evidence.
- People who work night shifts are likely to sleep less and/or more poorly than regular day workers.
As for ways to reduce these health risks among shift workers, Saunders says the research on such strategies is scant. However, based on what is available, he says promising approaches include restricting the number of evening or night shifts in a row to three, limiting weekend work, moving from backward to forward shift rotations, and using a participatory approach to the design of shift schedules.
We need more research on ways to mitigate the harmful effects of shift work on health, says Saunders.
That will require partnerships between workplaces and researchers in testing the potential benefits associated with different interventions.
To download the full Issue Briefing on shift work and health, go to: www.iwh.on.ca/issue-briefings.
Source: At Work, Issue 60, Spring 2010: Institute for Work & Health, Toronto